Earlier this week, a Learjet fell out of the sky, crashing into a street near West Palm Beach, Florida, leaving not much more than a huge crater in the road. It's possible that no cockpit voice recorder could have survived that transonic crash. Early speculation ran wild as to what could have been the cause, so I held off on commenting until now that the traffic control tapes have been released. I'll continue to edit this as more information and analysis comes out, but I'll start with a summary.
I wrote earlier about ice causing planes to fall out of the sky; that's very unlikely to be what happened here. I've also written about pilots flying their planes directly into a thunderstorm because their weather radar indicated a hole in the storm; that is indeed what appears to have happened here. The plane was torn apart by the tremendous turbulence in a rapidly developing thunderhead, and at that point the only thing that could have saved it was a Ballistic Recovery System--and those massive parachutes aren't available for Learjets.
Some quick takeaways from this crash:
• Pilots will continue to make errors. In a Learjet 60 at altitude, there is little margin for error, so regardless of what changes the NTSB recommends coming out of this, a similar event is likely to happen again.
• It's clear that weather radars are still not immune to luring pilots into the heart of a thunderstorm. I suspect that recommended changes will focus on either further redesign of radars, or further efforts to train pilots to resist this siren song.
UPDATE:
I'm genuinely confused about something, but before I research it further, I'll just throw out there how odd it seems that the copilot could, while traveling at near transonic speed along the edge of the troposphere, use a cell phone to inform a fellow pilot of icing and turbulence. What about the theory, strongly pushed by 9/11 conspiracy theorists, that cell phones only work when a plane is flying slowly or near the ground?